Read it in one sitting. The tension is unbearable in the best way and the ending recontextualizes everything.

By:J.T. Geissinger
Pen Pal follows Kayla, a grieving young widow and children’s book illustrator, whose life unravels further when she begins receiving unsettlingly intimate letters from a stranger in prison who insists he knows her and is willing to wait for her forever. As she tries to rebuild her world in the creaking old house she shared with her husband, Kayla grows closer to a protective contractor working on her home while strange, possibly supernatural occurrences intensify around her, blurring the line between grief, obsession, and something otherworldly. The story blends dark romance, gothic atmosphere, and psychological suspense, gradually revealing how the mysterious inmate, the haunting in her house, and Kayla’s own past are all connected, while keeping the central twist hidden until the end.
9 ratings8 reviews
Read it in one sitting. The tension is unbearable in the best way and the ending recontextualizes everything.

QA fixture review by QA Reader on pen-pal. Deterministic test body.

QA fixture review by admin on pen-pal. Deterministic body.

QA fixture review by blocked on pen-pal. Deterministic body.

Private reader
This reader keeps their reviews private.


QA fixture review by reader5 on pen-pal. Deterministic body.

Stay on top of every upcoming release from the series you love without the extra effort. Sign up to get updates tailored to your reading preferences and never miss what’s next.